• Home
  • CuriousCat Archive

CuriousCat Archive Page 164 of 202

Questions and Answers

  1. Published on May 27, 2019, 10:14 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Your friend told you he was an atheist and spent the entire rest of the day berating him about it?

    in response to I see. When discussing these issues, I tend to use different phrases (“patriarchy” to “strict gender roles” and “toxic masculinity” to “bully mentality”) because I worry these phrases can invoke a stop-thinking-and-start-shouting defense mechanism in some men. Did you ever have that reaction when you were young?

    Ian replied:

    I was 10!

  2. Published on May 27, 2019, 8:35 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I see. When discussing these issues, I tend to use different phrases (“patriarchy” to “strict gender roles” and “toxic masculinity” to “bully mentality”) because I worry these phrases can invoke a stop-thinking-and-start-shouting defense mechanism in some men. Did you ever have that reaction when you were young?

    in response to Do you consider concepts like “patriarchy”, “toxic masculinity” or “privilege” to be “mainstream”, aka “understood by most people”? I feel like a lot of The DiscourseTM is still stuck around these (to me easy to understand) concepts that Idk if it’s largely beause of right-wingers astroturfing or if people are just that ignorant

    Ian replied:

    Oh yeah. In elementary school, my friend told me he was an atheist and spent the entire rest of the day berating him about it. The Right is extremely comprehensible if you just think like an angry 4th grader.

  3. Published on May 27, 2019, 4:42 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Do you consider concepts like “patriarchy”, “toxic masculinity” or “privilege” to be “mainstream”, aka “understood by most people”? I feel like a lot of The DiscourseTM is still stuck around these (to me easy to understand) concepts that Idk if it’s largely beause of right-wingers astroturfing or if people are just that ignorant

    Ian replied:

    It really is hard to tell, isn't it? I have no idea how well the average person on the street understands toxic masculinity, or if they're even familiar with the term. All I know is, whatever The Discourse looks like is probably not wholly representative, but I don't know by how much.

  4. Published on May 27, 2019, 4:39 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Which was the better film from Jordan peele? Get Out or Us?

    And you were mentioning about how Us seem problematic in expressing its themes? So you meant that it's confusing?

    Ian replied:

    I found Get Out both more moment-to-moment enjoyable and also more coherent. Us is about a lot of stuff, and some of the stuff it's about seems - to me - in conflict with the other stuff it's about, and, as much as people argue from the assumption that this confusion is intentional, I'm not wholly convinced. The idea that Peele had a lot of ideas and a lot of ambition and didn't entire bring them together this time still strikes me as plausible.

  5. Published on May 27, 2019, 2:58 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I want to see a world where everyone is collectively rich, regardless of gender

    in response to Do you personally want to see a world with more independently rich women?

    Ian replied:

    If everyone has the same amount of money, nobody's rich.

  6. Published on May 27, 2019, 12:36 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    How come you never played Halo before?

    The first one was also playable in Mac too

    But I do get it if you're not interested. Though it's sci-fi, it's very pro-military and it fetish military hardware (especially the alien side called the Covenant) which makes Michael Bay look like a saint in comparison

    Also, Halo 1 has really good plot twists in the end (which ends up being derivative as the series progressed)

    Ian replied:

    I'm not aware that I need a reason to have not played Halo.

  7. Published on May 27, 2019, 12:35 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Do you personally want to see a world with more independently rich women?

    Ian replied:

    I want to see a world with fewer independently rich men.

  8. Published on May 27, 2019, 1:17 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I miss you.

    Ian replied:

    I miss you too.

  9. Published on May 26, 2019, 7:49 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    with a Niche like that open, I might try it out, but I don't know nearly enough about game analysis to fake being an expert. Are there any sources you'd recomend?

    in response to Would you be willing to do more videos on individual adventure games? The genre doesn't get enough love online. And the only long-form videos I know of are just Speed-runners showing how to finish a P&C as fast as possible without giving any thought or critique on the actual quality of the game. I know this isn't really your genre, but outside of Errant Signal, and his stuff isn't really in the Long dive into the game itself that I'm looking for. He more covers the meta-narrative of the game's themes and its development

    Ian replied:

    If you want to talk about adventure games, Andrew Plotkin, Emily Short, and Clara Fernandez-Vara are all good folks to start with.

  10. Published on May 26, 2019, 7:48 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    So I noticed that the show tunes at the beginning of the videos fit thematically with what the videos are about (someone's got to be oppressed was my fav btw) but I couldn't make out what the song before "Card Says Moops" was saying. What were the lyrics?

    Ian replied:

    It's Oom-Pah-Pah from Oliver! The line is:

    "Whether it's hidden or whether it shows,
    It's the same oom-pah-pah."

    I meant it to resonate with the closing Vonnegut quote, "We are what we pretend to be." Whether a person is open about their bigotry, hiding it from you, or hiding it from themselves, it's all still bigotry. How much irony is involved really doesn't matter that much. It's the same oom-pah-pah.

  11. Published on May 26, 2019, 3:01 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Whats the difference between interrelated media and a media studies degree?

    Ian replied:

    They don't really have much to do with each other. Media Studies is an academic field focused on analyzing mass communication, like TV and the internet. As far as I know, MassArt is the only school that has an Interrelated Media degree, and it's a Fine Arts program, as in you make and present art for credit. What makes the Studio for Interrelated Media different from the other departments is it's an interdisciplinary major - you can produce art in ANY medium, and it will get critiqued by people who specialize in a dozen or so disciplines. You also learn a lot about production: students are in charge of presenting each other's work, so if, on a given day, there are two videos, one performance, one installation, and one piece of wall art, the producers have to arrange the space and tech to accommodate it all. A lot of folks from the Studio for Interrelated Media go on to work crew for live theatre or music venues.

  12. Published on May 26, 2019, 2:59 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    This is a bit more complex than that - Mao for example is well known and to some extent respected on the left for his theoretical work even though he was very authoritarian.

    The main problem seems to be that revolutions are either taken over by authoritarians or destroyed from the outside by the imperialist core.

    Do you think there is a way to do a radicaly left policy anywhere in the world and not be assassinated/imprisoned with the help of the US other than protecting yourself with authoritarian policies ? How ?

    in response to Were the authoritarians cynics, true believers of emancipation and freedom for the people, or something else?

    Ian replied:

    That question is the biggest reason I hesitate when people call for socialist revolution. I don't know what differentiates the revolutions that get coopted by authoritarians from the ones that don't.

  13. Published on May 26, 2019, 2:57 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Would you be willing to do more videos on individual adventure games? The genre doesn't get enough love online. And the only long-form videos I know of are just Speed-runners showing how to finish a P&C as fast as possible without giving any thought or critique on the actual quality of the game.

    I know this isn't really your genre, but outside of Errant Signal, and his stuff isn't really in the Long dive into the game itself that I'm looking for. He more covers the meta-narrative of the game's themes and its development

    Ian replied:

    I pretty much only make a video if I feel I have something I want to say, so I can't really commit to talking more or less about adventure games. I'll talk about a individual adventure game if I play one that makes me wanna talk about it. But I think odds are pretty good that I'll do that from time to time, since it is my favorite genre and, like you, I feel there isn't enough critical analysis of them.

    In the meantime, though: check out Pushing Up Roses' videos on adventure games ( https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLcXUr4OJhR1Yy0RiqaJuP3OLqoZrm_8BE ) and Andrew Plotkin's text reviews ( https://eblong.com/zarf/gamerev/index.html ). They may not *quite* be the deep dives you're looking for, but they scratch an itch for me that most other gaming discourse doesn't.

  14. Published on May 25, 2019, 8:32 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Why are the left failing so hard at elections?

    Ian replied:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MAbab8aP4_A

  15. Published on May 25, 2019, 8:31 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Thoughts on Black Mirror?

    Ian replied:

    had some good episodes early on

  16. Published on May 25, 2019, 8:28 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Hi! I love your series. I didn't know you had one of these.

    I have passed your video on to a few friends, and although they love the variety which focuses on non-online discourse (You Go High, We Go Low; Death of a Euphemism), they don't seem to enjoy the online-discourse focused ones. That is, ones featuring discussions of Anita Sarkeesian (who, although attained some internet fame, is almost totally non-existent in the eye of people who are just, like, thinking about Brexit).

    Two questions:

    1. Do you have any plans to tackle Brexit as a topic? Or are you just not familiar enough with the UK political landscape? Many of your videos feel very pointed at the US — and the UK has its own set of institutional, systemic issues.

    2. Do your videos, on your end, perform better when they stray from online discourse into mainstream-salient content? i.e. parsable by the average person who just does not know what a troll is

    Ian replied:

    1. No plans to talk about Brexit. Olly and Hbomb are already speaking on that with much more authority than I could.

    2. If you're not talking about online, you're not talking about modern fascism.

    The next ARP is going to get more explicit about this, but the Nazis went digital around 2013 and the Left *has not caught up*. Online is where they organize, where they radicalize, where they host disinformation, and where they recruit. There are a lot of ways that this shift has changed white nationalism, from the ways it's expanded their influence to the ways its cost them control over their followers, but there isn't a comprehensive means of addressing online fascism the way there has been for addressing in-the-streets fascism. The series is called The Alt-Right Playbook, so, yeah, it's going to deal with the playbook the Alt-Right actually uses.

    Your friends who don't follow the online stuff? Getting their heads around it is the whole point.

  17. Published on May 25, 2019, 8:16 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Were the authoritarians cynics, true believers of emancipation and freedom for the people, or something else?

    in response to I'm asking sincerely here. You mention in one of your videos "if you want to fight fascist, move left" but you have said that a lot of workers or revolutionary parties go into power and then suddenly get coopted by authoritarians. Isn't this a contradiction? If we're moving Left and thus moving more and more into a violent revolution and suddenly authoritarians are in power this feels like a contradiction. Political cadres, Vanguardism, Social Responsibility Tests, Exporting the Revolution. These are Leftist policies through and through are they not?

    Ian replied:

    I haven't done a ton of research, but to the best of my understanding they were people who took advantage of a power vacuum after the revolution to seize power for themselves.

  18. Published on May 25, 2019, 1:02 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Why are americans afraid of fruits and veggies so much???

    Ian replied:

    we Americans are not fond of things that are good for us

  19. Published on May 25, 2019, 1:01 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    ey boss, can i habe a pizza pls?

    in response to can i have a pizza please?

    Ian replied:

    sir, don't taunt the drive-thru workers

  20. Published on May 25, 2019, 1:00 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I'm asking sincerely here. You mention in one of your videos "if you want to fight fascist, move left" but you have said that a lot of workers or revolutionary parties go into power and then suddenly get coopted by authoritarians.

    Isn't this a contradiction? If we're moving Left and thus moving more and more into a violent revolution and suddenly authoritarians are in power this feels like a contradiction. Political cadres, Vanguardism, Social Responsibility Tests, Exporting the Revolution. These are Leftist policies through and through are they not?

    Ian replied:

    No. Leftist revolution does not always result in authoritarian coopting.

  21. Published on May 25, 2019, 12:57 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    where do you lean ideologically? democratic socialist, marxist, etc.
    and why would you prefer that one

    Ian replied:

    I haven't really picked an -ism. The general tenets of socialism resonate with me and I'm fully done with capitalism, but I haven't sat down and read all the theory and history. Hence, I tend to call myself a lefty or pinko or some other noncommittal-but-left-of-liberal term.

  22. Published on May 24, 2019, 1:28 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    can i have a pizza please?

    Ian replied:

    sir, this is an arby's

  23. Published on May 24, 2019, 1:28 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    so you reckoned now that TV is currently going through a golden age?

    I think that TV is having a sort of renaissance,

    but I also think that it’s a kind of a misnomer

    in response to In a world filled with sequels, prequels, remakes, and reboots, is creativity dying in Hollywood?

    Ian replied:

    I don't know. I don't watch a lot of TV.

  24. Published on May 24, 2019, 4:04 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I'm a different person than the one who asked this question, but it seems like a "fake it 'til you make it" approach might work here. If you believe strongly enough in the kind of world you want to create, that belief can give you the energy you need to create that world.

    in response to Been finding it hard to enjoy things knowing how close humanity’s going to screw itself by global warming and all bad things that are happening. Don’t suppose you have any advice on this?

    Ian replied:

    it's pretty much our last hope

  25. Published on May 23, 2019, 10:38 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    You know, I wouldn’t even throw a milkshake at Sargon. Would you?

    Ian replied:

    I'm vegan, so I don't often have a milkshake on hand.

  26. Published on May 23, 2019, 10:37 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Is animal farm a really good example why socialism/communism is bad or is it just a cop-out for captialist bootlickers?

    Ian replied:

    Uh, Orwell was a socialist, friend.

  27. Published on May 22, 2019, 9:02 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Have you ever successfully convinced anyone out of their values-neutral governance mindset? Like convinving people that yes, milkshaking fascists is good

    Ian replied:

    I've made this argument elsewhere:

    Changing your mind about something major is not an event, it's a process. It takes many points of contact with an idea before you are willing to fully accept it. Points of contact may be having life experiences, reading data, or conversation. Let's imagine it takes 100 points of contact to change your mind.

    The conversation you're having right now, where the other person would appear to be making all kinds of sense and yet their argument is having seemingly no effect on you? Maybe it's just number 35.

    Number 35 is just as important number 100, but it's not as noticeable how.

    I have not been present for many 100s, but I hope I've been a fair number of 35s.

  28. Published on May 22, 2019, 8:56 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Been finding it hard to enjoy things knowing how close humanity’s going to screw itself by global warming and all bad things that are happening. Don’t suppose you have any advice on this?

    Ian replied:

    I say "we still have time to fix things," which is either optimism or denial. But if denial gives me what I need to keep working on the problems, maybe it's not so bad.

  29. Published on May 22, 2019, 1:01 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    So would you consider doing a video on polyamory?

    Ian replied:

    No.

  30. Published on May 22, 2019, 1:01 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Ever been to Louisiana?

    Ian replied:

    Been through it.

  31. Published on May 22, 2019, 1:01 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    You think that Anomalisa was a bit more of an optimistic film from Charlie Kaufman? It's like he's still writing and filming with a cracked lens but at least for Anomalisa, he's allowing a bit of light into what's in front of the lens

    I think Sycnedoche: New York was so pessimistic about humanity and life in general and tone that it's just unintentionally hilarious

    Ian replied:

    Oof, Anomalisa is about a complete inability to maintain connection with people, and being utterly alone in the prison of one's own mind. "Optimistic" is not the word I would choose.

  32. Published on May 22, 2019, 12:57 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    In a world filled with sequels, prequels, remakes, and reboots,

    is creativity dying in Hollywood?

    Ian replied:

    Creativity and Hollywood have always been strange bedfellows, and Hollywood has always churned out derivative works. When we look at film history, we don't see as many, because most were forgettable. The concentration is higher now than before, but not by much.

  33. Published on May 22, 2019, 12:56 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What is your opinion on anti-psychiatry?

    Ian replied:

    it bad

  34. Published on May 22, 2019, 12:55 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Basically Races doesn't exist, including white, but to effectively resist racist we have to accept their definitions. correct?

    Ian replied:

    Race is a social construct, but social constructs are real.

  35. Published on May 21, 2019, 2:22 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What part of your research brought you to the conclusion that reactionaries are hiding their beliefs from themselves, and not just others?

    Ian replied:

    There's plenty of evidence, but the most obvious is it's the way a lot of them talk to each other even when they think no lefties are watching.

  36. Published on May 21, 2019, 2:21 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    It's kind of specific, but have you come on any difference in the feelings of western white supremacist towards Slavs during the cold war and today? (We know how the original nazis felt about them)

    Ian replied:

    I know nothing about that, sorry.

  37. Published on May 21, 2019, 2:20 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Why is your original youtube channel's name "mrskimp"?

    Ian replied:

    why anything?

  38. Published on May 19, 2019, 3:50 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Sorry, poor wording. The "them" we're trying to trick in that last sentence refers to white supremacists who want fewer non-white births.
    Like, if they're going to believe something as absurd as "the great replacrment," do you think we could convince someone like tomi lahren to get on board with overturning the abortion ban in pursuit of that absurd goal?

    in response to O.k., hear me out -- poor poc are disproportionally affected by abortion bans. Any chance we can leverage molyneux-type "great replacement" white supremacists to trick them into helping overturn the bans?

    Ian replied:

    I think that's a pretty bad idea.

  39. Published on May 19, 2019, 4:23 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    God I'm so confused

    in response to There's different ethnicities within white people. White Spaniards are a specific ethnicity like Anglo-Saxons aren't Slavic people.

    Ian replied:

    Folks, you know I love you all, but the effort y'all spend asking me what the difference is between race and ethnicity could be spent finding the answers yourself on Wikipedia.

  40. Published on May 18, 2019, 2:59 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    O.k., hear me out -- poor poc are disproportionally affected by abortion bans. Any chance we can leverage molyneux-type "great replacement" white supremacists to trick them into helping overturn the bans?

    Ian replied:

    Poor POC who want abortions don't need to be tricked into opposing bans on abortions.

  41. Published on May 18, 2019, 12:40 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Is Melee the only Smash game that catches your interest or have you been enjoying any of the Ultimate stuff?

    Ian replied:

    I enjoy playing Ultimate, but not spectating it.

  42. Published on May 17, 2019, 3:36 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Are-- are we the baddies?

    As in, America? Is America the baddies?

    Ian replied:

    You know that scene on The Venture Brothers where Dr. Venture almost becomes a supervillain without realizing it, and backs away at the last second but recognizes that turning evil would be a logical outcome of the path he's been going down all his life, and he turns to Brock and asks, "I'm not a bad guy, am I?" and Brock goes "ennnnhhhhh" and does one of those 50/50 gestures with his hand?

    Yeah...

  43. Published on May 17, 2019, 3:31 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Would such drastic restrictions be feasible to implement in such a short time? (and I hate that I have to ask this if it could actually happen, but hey, hellworld)

    in response to What will right-wingers do next should they succeed in overturning Roe v Wade? I see a lot of people on twitter comparing it to "the handmaid's tale", but I don't watch the show so I'm a still a bit confused.

    Ian replied:

    I don't predict the future. The point is, when you see a number of things getting worse for marginalized people at an increasing pace, you should be *very* alert.

  44. Published on May 17, 2019, 1:16 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What will right-wingers do next should they succeed in overturning Roe v Wade? I see a lot of people on twitter comparing it to "the handmaid's tale", but I don't watch the show so I'm a still a bit confused.

    Ian replied:

    The premise of The Handmaid's Tale is New England becoming an independent religious theocracy that forces fertile women into service as child-bearers for men and ships them off to The Colonies to die of radiation poisoning if they don't conceive.

    One of the themes of the book is how life for women gets incrementally more restrictive in ways that are problematic but don't seem like imminent crises, but then, suddenly, in a matter of weeks women are disallowed from working, their bank accounts are frozen, and transit out of state is forbidden.

    So, while I don't know how bad things will get, the fact that they're getting bad faster and faster is distressing.

  45. Published on May 15, 2019, 9:28 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    There's different ethnicities within white people. White Spaniards are a specific ethnicity like Anglo-Saxons aren't Slavic people.

    Ian replied:

    No shit. Guess what? Black Spaniards and white Spaniards are the same ethnicity.

  46. Published on May 15, 2019, 5:30 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    To be honest, now I am totally confused. Why it's racist malarkey to say certain ethnicities are white/black/asian? How then you would say person is white/black/asian? Simply by their looks?

    For example, how would you answer my question if I have asked are Russian people white? Well, I think you would say the same, "white russian are white", even though Russian people as ethnic group and Russian people as citizenship goes are two different things. Nobody would argue that Buryats are white, but they don't belong to Russian ethnic group, they are different ethnic group called Buryats and they are asian, even though they are Russian.

    Why it's racist then to say spaniards are white?

    Also, before you say, there are few Russians who are black and/or muslim, it doesn't make Russians as ethnicity any less white.

    in response to You are being willfully obtuse here. Spaniards is ethnicity. I didn't ask about Spanish people. Of course there Spanish people who are black, just like there are Scottish people who are black, but that doesn't mean that Scottish people as ethnic group aren't white. Spaniards is not the same as Spanish people. So, back to my original question, are spaniards considered white?

    Ian replied:

    A caliphate of North African Muslims ruled 1/3 of the country for 200 years, and you're asking me why it's racist to say their descendants, who have been there for over a millennium, are not Spaniards because they're not white?

    Is that a serious question?

  47. Published on May 15, 2019, 12:53 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    In "The Card Says Moops" you said that 'Englebert will sometimes make a Charlamagne argument and vice versa... and the left does the same thing but that's a false equivalence'.

    My question is, what're some examples of the left engaging in "The Card Says Moops" rhetoric, and why is that a false equivalence? (love your channel btw, huge fan)

    Ian replied:

    Anyone who values winning an argument over being rhetorically consistent will fall into this. People on the Left are guilty of it, too. I've certainly had arguments in my younger days where I just kind of reached for any rhetoric that would tell me the other person was wrong, even if it wasn't consistent with what I'd said earlier. Any time a liberal makes an egalitarian argument like "corporations should pay their fair share" and, in the next breath, makes a hierarchical argument like "you should vote with your dollar," you're seeing a conflict of ideology.

    The reason it's a false equivalence is that the Right does this far more pervasively, far more blatantly, and far more destructively than the Left. The whole reason they say "the Left does it too" is to reframe the behavior as a binary - either your side does it, or not. They seek to ignore scale. Conservative ideology creates so much cognitive dissonance that the only defense is to insist "everybody does this, no one actually believes in anything, we all just say whatever we need to win." And it's not true.

  48. Published on May 15, 2019, 12:45 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Have you played The Fall? I got hooked on the premise and its downloading as I type. ("Do the Bidding of An Evil AI" Portal-a-like to do with applying an essentially violent skillset to mundane puzzle solving tasks. The player is a femme coded exosuit trying to get medical help for their pilot.)

    It's apparently very well regarded so I thought you'd have good odds of having tried it. And I value your opinion so I thought you'd have good odds of having something interesting to say if you had.

    Ian replied:

    I haven't, but I just watched the trailer and it looks... good!

  49. Published on May 15, 2019, 12:39 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    You are being willfully obtuse here. Spaniards is ethnicity. I didn't ask about Spanish people. Of course there Spanish people who are black, just like there are Scottish people who are black, but that doesn't mean that Scottish people as ethnic group aren't white. Spaniards is not the same as Spanish people. So, back to my original question, are spaniards considered white?

    in response to There are black people almost in every country, but you wouldn't say for example "white chinese are white because there are also black people in China". You are being willfully obtuse. First sentence on wikipedia article "Spaniards"

    Ian replied:

    You are asking if the white people in Spain are white; I've already said they are. The only reason you're still talking to me is you want me to accept a definition of "Spaniard" that excludes Black, Muslim, and Romani Spaniards. Not only will I not do that - it's racist malarkey - it's tautological to begin with. If you're defining "Spaniard" as "white," why ask if they're white?

  50. Published on May 15, 2019, 1:30 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Good question! I actually haven't read the other stuff you have, so it's hard for me to say.

    What I took away from it was an understanding of fascism less as a specific political beliefs but more as a narrative of unjust loss of power and a fated return, much like the palingenetic ultranationalism point. Paxton also talks at length, however, about the political circumstances that tend to birth fascism, such as an ineffectual left and discontent with the mainstream right. That's not something I've seen mentioned in your Alt-Right Playbook work so far, so it might be a useful read for that perspective?

    in response to I was looking over your reading list (which is a fantastic resource; thanks so much), and I noticed you didn't have The Anatomy of Fascism by Robert Paxton on there. I'd like to suggest it! I read it during the '16 election and found it really useful at outlining a theory of fascism and how it develops. Have you read it?

    Ian replied:

    Hmm. Some of the stuff I've read has covered similar stuff, though this might go into better depth on it. I'm always torn about this, because people sometimes recommend me books that sounds better than the ones I've read on those topics, but I can't tell if they'll give me *new* information or just the same information *better explained*. I feel like I'm always under a mountain of research and I'm loathe to add more if I don't know how much new info it will add. Ugh!

  51. Published on May 14, 2019, 9:10 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I was looking over your reading list (which is a fantastic resource; thanks so much), and I noticed you didn't have The Anatomy of Fascism by Robert Paxton on there. I'd like to suggest it! I read it during the '16 election and found it really useful at outlining a theory of fascism and how it develops.

    Have you read it?

    Ian replied:

    I haven't! Do you feel it will say stuff that the other books and essays on fascism won't?

  52. Published on May 14, 2019, 12:55 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Have you tried those new Snapchat feature turning yourself into a lady?

    Enjoying it so far?

    Ian replied:

    I did that back when it was called FaceApp.

  53. Published on May 13, 2019, 11:03 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I picked up a neat little tidbit of information from a video.

    Apparently youtube promotes monetized content more than it promotes unmonetized content.

    Is this as true as it is for content that was never monetized as it is for content that was once monetized but was later deemed ineligible?

    Ian replied:

    You already know more than I do. YouTube doesn't actually tell us how its algorithms work.

  54. Published on May 13, 2019, 11:02 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    will there be a chapter in the Alt-Right playbook about how the Right's demand and practice of public "debates" are in bad faith? (if so, god save your soul knowing you'll have to hear Shapiro's voice at length to research it)

    in response to i think the left and right tend to have different applications of an 'echo chamber'? like, im a gay trans man and what some (mostly the right, it seems) would call an 'echo chamber' for me is just being around people affirming that i exist and deserve human rights. it seems like both the left and right have the general 'thoughts without dissent or diversity' definition of an echo chamber, but how that's applied is different?

    Ian replied:

    Yeah, that was... that was the first episode after the introduction.

  55. Published on May 13, 2019, 4:36 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    i think the left and right tend to have different applications of an 'echo chamber'? like, im a gay trans man and what some (mostly the right, it seems) would call an 'echo chamber' for me is just being around people affirming that i exist and deserve human rights. it seems like both the left and right have the general 'thoughts without dissent or diversity' definition of an echo chamber, but how that's applied is different?

    Ian replied:

    In my experience, the Right says "echo chamber" in the same sentence that they say "debate me."

  56. Published on May 13, 2019, 4:22 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    its...esoteric to say the least yeah
    i recommend watching a playthrough if you cant get into it, you get the same experience essentially

    in response to thoughts on killer7 and its themes?

    Ian replied:

    Nah, I'll probably play it, I just dunno when.

  57. Published on May 13, 2019, 4:19 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Is echo chambers on the left something we should be concerned about online? In a way I feel that even if your'e only listening to Liberal and radical-lefty sources your in a very different situation intellectually than a person that listens to "both" alt-right and conservative sources.

    in response to Still trying to piece together why GoT went the way it did. Do you think this is another How I Met Your Mother case where they try to follow an old ending that was written before all this annoying "character development" thingy happened? Or are they just trying to outsmart the viewers and be 'schoking"?

    Ian replied:

    You should be concerned about echo chambers in any part of life, but let's talk about what the Left and the Right do and don't know about each other.

    The Right - especially the Very Online Right - spends a lot more time seeking direct, combative engagement with the Left, which they try to spin as stepping out of their echo chambers. Conversely, the Left spends a lot more time researching the subjects the Right is talking about and what the Right is saying about them. And a result of this (and several other factors) is that the Left generally understands what the Right is doing and saying where the Right has only a caricatured notion of what the Left cares about, but the Right can predict and account for the behaviors of the Left where the Left still vaguely assumes that healthy discourse will sort everything out.

    Or, in briefer language: the Right knows the Left's behavior, the Left know's the Right's rhetoric, and neither is really engaging with the other's ideology.

    I think "echo chamber" is a very misused term these days. Speaking from my own experience, there is a huge diversity of thought on the Left, and I am constantly having my beliefs challenged and enriched by other lefties, whereas much of my direct engagement with the Right is having the same handful of arguments repeated over and over. I don't need to hear much more from them to know what they believe. Also, I get their opinions shouted at me every day; I DREAM of the peace an echo chamber would bring.

    But I think stepping outside of one's echo chamber needs to be done with some intentionality. The Left's default is to read an article, the Right's is to pick a fight. But are either of these things actually teaching us what we need to know? Where are our misunderstandings, and what information do we need to correct them? My research doesn't involve a lot of talking with reactionaries because I did a lot of that and it stopped yielding results. If I want to understand what the Right believes - not what they *say* but what they *believe* - I need a wider context. So I read about fascism, about white supremacy, even about cults, and when I dip a toe back into the Right's rhetoric, it makes a different kind of sense.

    Basically what I'm saying is: when you step out of your echo chamber, have a strategy. And don't do it just because somebody guilted you, you probably won't learn anything that way.

  58. Published on May 13, 2019, 12:19 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Still trying to piece together why GoT went the way it did. Do you think this is another How I Met Your Mother case where they try to follow an old ending that was written before all this annoying "character development" thingy happened? Or are they just trying to outsmart the viewers and be 'schoking"?

    Ian replied:

    The writers either don't understand what made the earlier seasons good, or understand but can't replicate it. All they have left that they're competent at is battle scenes and portentously repeating lines from the good seasons. It all just reeks of what a 10-year-old thinks "grown-up stuff" looks like.

  59. Published on May 13, 2019, 12:15 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    So, how fucking tired are you of Campbellian monomyth being treated as the One, True blueprint for proper storytelling (for any kind of adventure story, at least), rather than one analytical lens to view storytelling through?

    Or is that just me?

    Ian replied:

    Not as tired as some, but still quite sleepy.

  60. Published on May 13, 2019, 12:15 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    thoughts on killer7 and its themes?

    Ian replied:

    I have a copy for GameCube but haven't really dug into it. All I can say is the controls are... unintuitive.

  61. Published on May 13, 2019, 3:09 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    With your most recent video on what conservatives believe is it safe to assume you are not a capitalist?

    Ian replied:

    Correct.

    You must be new here.

  62. Published on May 13, 2019, 3:09 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Are you getting a gaming PC?

    Ian replied:

    I'm still maybe thinking of crowdfunding a gaming laptop.

  63. Published on May 13, 2019, 3:08 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Then what is it that was unoriginal?

    in response to you said avengers endgame had unoriginal ideas did you mean by the time travel logic? i mean it seems new though not truthfully scientific-backed

    Ian replied:

    the entire middle third is literally going back to the plots of previous movies

  64. Published on May 12, 2019, 1:06 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Tbf they've been calling you old for a very long time :) (I'm just joking you really don't look old at all).
    I remember when I was 19 and every adult still looked 'old' even if they were like 25 ^^

    in response to How did you manage to simultaneously look old, young and dashing at the same time?

    Ian replied:

    this is RUDE and not a question

  65. Published on May 12, 2019, 1:06 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    you said avengers endgame had unoriginal ideas

    did you mean by the time travel logic? i mean it seems new though not truthfully scientific-backed

    Ian replied:

    no. I wasn't talking about the time travel.

  66. Published on May 11, 2019, 11:11 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Being John Malkovich or The Handmaiden?

    Ian replied:

    Handmaiden.

  67. Published on May 11, 2019, 11:11 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What do you think of the first Deus Ex?

    Ian replied:

    it good

  68. Published on May 11, 2019, 1:46 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    As someone who got into politics after Milo became irrelevant, it surprises me to look back at how much fame he got for being a right-wing troll with absolutely less than anything worthwhile to say. I’m not familiar with America educational system, but how do peole like him get invited to speak at colleges?

    Ian replied:

    I'm assuming it's mostly getting his fans who are students to request him.

  69. Published on May 11, 2019, 1:45 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Do you think that conservatives accusing everything they don't like of being "socialist/communist" can actually help mainstreaming these concepts? (similar to how they rabidly calling everyone they don't like "sjews", which actually led to me checking out "sjews" channels like hbomb and shaun).

    Ian replied:

    Yeah, I've seen folks point out that, for people who grew up after the Cold War ended, "socialism" doesn't really conjure images of bread lines and dictators, and Republicans have done a bang-up job making "socialism" synonymous with free healthcare, universal basic income, job security, and environmental justice. You call everything that makes the world better "socialism" and socialism doesn't look so bad to people.

  70. Published on May 11, 2019, 1:42 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    How did you manage to simultaneously look old, young and dashing at the same time?

    Ian replied:

    why people gotta tell me I look old?

  71. Published on May 11, 2019, 4:01 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Is it possible for Captain Marval to be salvaged if put into better hands? Or should we just wait till Kamala Khan replace her?

    in response to A criticism I've often seen is that Captain Marvel/Brie Larson wasn't "likable" enough, and I feeeeeel like there's some misogynistic undertone there. I mean, she's not any more dry and sarcastic than say Iron Man or Doctor Strange. Do you feel the same?

    Ian replied:

    She's got all the elements of a fun as heck movie if someone just wrote her a better script.

  72. Published on May 10, 2019, 12:38 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    wait wasnt biden like a fun uncle when he was obama's VP, what happened lmao

    Ian replied:

    Being Obama's VP was an effective rebrand of a historically centrist and creepy dude.

  73. Published on May 10, 2019, 12:37 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    A criticism I've often seen is that Captain Marvel/Brie Larson wasn't "likable" enough, and I feeeeeel like there's some misogynistic undertone there. I mean, she's not any more dry and sarcastic than say Iron Man or Doctor Strange. Do you feel the same?

    in response to Any thoughts on Captain Marvel? (assuming you've watched it)

    Ian replied:

    The script didn't give her a ton of personality, so there is a grain of truth to the "unlikability" critique, but the only reason it's more than a minor complaint about an okay movie is misogyny. They settled on "unlikable" well before they saw the movie.

  74. Published on May 9, 2019, 11:49 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Asking as someone who reluctantly voted for Clinton in 2016, if Biden is the democratic nominee, what would even be the point of voting? As his nomination becomes increasingly likely, I've been very frustrated that we have two right wing parties and I can't find any will to want to vote or participate at all

    Ian replied:

    I am disgusted at the very idea of Biden being President, but can we please - PLEASE - not pretend he'd be no better than Trump? Biden will not enact a Muslim ban. Biden will not try to repeal abortion. Biden will not make white nationalists feel empowered to murder people. Biden will not provoke a war with Iran by accident. These are hideously low bars and the fact that clearing them and nothing else is all Biden can offer us is depressing as hell, and, yes, Trump vs. Biden is essentially "do we want things to get bad fast or slow," but *slow is still better than fast*. And slow is easier than fast to bring to a stop.

    If it comes to it, I will hate every second of voting for Biden, but it will still beat the alternative.

  75. Published on May 9, 2019, 11:44 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    You said you want to cover more games this year? What games so you plan to make a video on?

    Ian replied:

    I have something in the works that's about games, but not any specific game.

    More than that, I shall not say.

Anon commented:
Ian replied:

CuriousCat is an anonymous Q&A social networking site. It is set to be discontinued on Oct 7, 2024.

This is an archive of the 15094 questions and answers from my CuriousCat page.

Previous Next

Site Credit: Arpit Agrawal