Ian replied:
Thing is, I don't think the Right *made* a pipeline intentionally. One of the reasons the pipeline is successful is because people contribute to it without trying to. PewDiePie didn't CHOOSE to be the middle rung of the PewDiePipeline, but he is. The pipeline is established through trial and error. Every rung is able to disavow their involvement, or even deny the pipeline exists, and, while this is often willful ignorance, many genuinely believe it isn't real and they aren't part of it.
I think that process of trial and error - simply following whatever is successful without a larger plan - is the product of there just being a SHITLOAD of reactionary YouTubers. Shaun did a whole video on how, any time a piece of news comes out that reactionaries can exploit, dozens and dozens of nearly identical videos come out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l63nY0AYebI
The sheer VOLUME of content means a lot of techniques can be tried at once, and copied if they are successful. It's basically the same way a virus evolves resistance to treatment.
At present, there aren't nearly enough LeftTubers to create such a system organically, especially since we don't chase the news as much. Also, when we make similar videos - e.g. Hbomberguy and Philosophy Tube both making flat earth videos - we tend to reference and build on each others' arguments instead of all saying the same things with minor variations.
Since LeftTube couldn't build a pipeline organically, we'd have to do it intentionally, and that just requires a degree of organization and a unity of purpose that we don't presently have. And, where the PewDiePipeline mutates based on anything that gets more clicks, any changes to the LeftTube pipeline would probably be the product of deliberation and compromise, which is slower.
Not saying it's a bad idea, and not saying I haven't considered something along those lines, but it's a lot of additional labor and I can't predict how many people would sign on.
Anonymous commented:
Do you think it's worth the effort for Lefttube to try to create a pipeline to turn people into leftists like the right does with their ideas?