• Home
  • CuriousCat Archive

CuriousCat Archive Page 24 of 202

Questions and Answers

  1. Published on Mar 2, 2024, 8:33 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    (diff. Anon) Genuine question, what are the other options? I read and watch a lot of your content and I never actually hear any alternatives to capitalism, genuinely disgusting as it is.

    in response to Stalin and Mao killed more people than Hitler and World War II. Pol Pot killed almost 1/3 Cambodians. The Kims and the Castros have left their countries in destitution and turned them into police states. Even "democratic" leftists like Hugo Chavez squandered Venezuela’s resources and now people have to line up for toilet paper. But sure, conservatives like Reagan, Thatcher, and Trump who didn’t even hold power for a decade were the real monsters…

    Ian replied:

    that's the next frontier for me. I wanna dig into the history and theory of socialist practice to get a sense of what is most worth trying and how to avoid past pitfalls.

  2. Published on Mar 2, 2024, 8:32 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Dang, whaddya got against wilhelm screams?

    in response to Worst thing they could put in Silksong that would make you drop it without a second thought?

    Ian replied:

    nothing against them when used well, but they do suit fit the vibe of a Hollow Knight game

  3. Published on Mar 2, 2024, 8:31 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Has Tucker Carlson recovered from being deplatformed?

    Ian replied:

    hell no

  4. Published on Mar 2, 2024, 3:20 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Definitely not. So are we saying that his rhetorical strategy of “get a big reaction” is flawed from the get-go, or are we just picking between the lesser of two evils? I’m really sorry if I’m missing the point here

    in response to Hello! Big fan. Not sure if you get this question a lot (apologies if so) but I’m still a little fuzzy on the ending of The Cost of Doing Business. In it, you mention that a strong enough protest against the Provocateur would dissuade them from hosting the speaking engagement in the first place, beating them at their own power game. While I agree this is an effective method, is it not still weak to the whole “all publicity is good publicity” strategy? Just intuitively, it feels like the Provocateur’s end goal of “cause enough outrage that Fox News has to platform me and my awful ideas” is more than fulfilled by a thousand-people strong protest. While I understand that the point is to not play by their rules and refuse to accept their terms of “attention as a stake”, is there no middle ground? It seems like the Provocateur by his very existence forces the left into a compromising position, where we either let him spew hate and fuck with immigrants or give him the attention he’s chasing. Is there no way to win?

    Ian replied:

    I would say the idea that "all attention is good attention" is flawed. it is OFTEN true that controversy and attention are beneficial, but there are clearly TYPES of controversy, TYPES of attention, that are devastating to people on the Right, so it's worth looking at what those types are, and where different provocateurs are weak.

    in the case of Milo, it turns out that his career was almost entirely propped up by wealthy benefactors - the Mercers for a while before he got cut off, then Alex Macris after Matthew Mellon died - and the mix of press that was ACTUALLY BAD and his expensive lifestyle finally made him a liability. he was never ACTUALLY financially solvent for anyone, near as I can tell.

    so: for a person in Milo's situation, protests can be useful in part because they compel his benefactors to shell out for more security at his events (especially, you know, after one of his followers FUCKING SHOT A PROTESTOR). maybe that puts him in a lot of newspapers and gets more eyeballs on him and helps his brand, but it also makes schools aware of what a risk it can be to bring him on campus, and jacks up his speaking fee to cover the added security. the pedophilia scandal was bad press in particular because him being a gay man already meant he was viewed with suspicion by the Right, and they LOVE to push the "queers are dangerous to children" narrative (which Milo's transphobia had helped mainstream), so once that hit the news, it was a good time for his backers to dump him. he might have survived it if he was making them money, or even just costing them less, but the protests plus the bad press finally brought him down.

    there are no hard-and-fast rules here, because each provocateur is different. Richard Spencer got taken down by a few punches to the head, but that probably wouldn't work on Milo. and Spencer might be harder to take down with financial pressure because he has a think tank backing him, which might be more resilient than solo-patrons. (or maybe not, I dunno his institute's financials.) point is: none of them are fully immune to bad press, and most of them are only successful due very particular circumstances and vested interests. they do not have huge, broad support. they all have weaknesses.

  5. Published on Mar 2, 2024, 1:17 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Which piece of media would benefit from having a Wilhelm scream added to it?

    in response to Worst thing they could put in Silksong that would make you drop it without a second thought?

    Ian replied:

    deep throat

  6. Published on Mar 1, 2024, 4:48 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Worst thing they could put in Silksong that would make you drop it without a second thought?

    Ian replied:

    a wilhelm scream

  7. Published on Mar 1, 2024, 4:47 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Are you zealous, of the jealous, and guitar picks with anarchics?

    in response to Do the outfits have the fascists?

    Ian replied:

    not so much, but I am martial to the partial, and a beaver hat to the plutocrats

  8. Published on Mar 1, 2024, 5:30 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Do the outfits have the fascists?

    Ian replied:

    and the music has the communists

  9. Published on Feb 28, 2024, 7:40 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Stalin and Mao killed more people than Hitler and World War II. Pol Pot killed almost 1/3 Cambodians. The Kims and the Castros have left their countries in destitution and turned them into police states. Even "democratic" leftists like Hugo Chavez squandered Venezuela’s resources and now people have to line up for toilet paper. But sure, conservatives like Reagan, Thatcher, and Trump who didn’t even hold power for a decade were the real monsters…

    in response to Should journalism have a left-wing bias?

    Ian replied:

    capitalism kills 183,000 people a year from poverty in the US alone, that's what we consider monstrous, and what Trump, Thatcher, and Reagan considered normal and good.

    I can see where they would look preferably to Pol Pot but it's really dishonest to pretend those are the only options.

  10. Published on Feb 28, 2024, 3:50 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I definitely think Folding Ideas could have made The Artist is Absent or maybe even This Is Phil Fish(not that he would have had the exact same arguments but they're the kind of video in his wheelhouse for me) but his Flat Earth video is the closest it comes to ARPB or Angry Jack and its a big gap still. I don't know any channel that has made anything particularly similar to Who Shot Guybrush Threepwood or Adventure Games About Jesus.

    In general I think the scope of topics you cover makes it hard to make connections but I do think Folding Ideas was probably the closest

    in response to Who on YT would you say is doing videos most similar to yours, TARP-wise?

  11. Published on Feb 28, 2024, 3:49 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Why are you like this

    in response to Lemme guess, Zodiac isn’t as deep or great or brilliant as we think it is, either, right?

    Ian replied:

    friend, I was in the film department at college. you haven't seen Like This. of the people who are Like This, I am the LEAST Like This.

  12. Published on Feb 28, 2024, 3:45 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Should journalism have a left-wing bias?

    Ian replied:

    reality has a left-wing bias

  13. Published on Feb 28, 2024, 4:44 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    (diffanon) There's no reason you couldn't have changed your favorite since then, though?

    in response to This anon forgot Smash 4

    Ian replied:

    Melee is a FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT game from the others

  14. Published on Feb 28, 2024, 4:43 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    (diff anon) I generally go by presentation style and in that case I put your work in the realm of like.... Well, let's just say that Shaun is mostly static. Contrapoints is in a live-action production-quality war with Hbomb. Jacob Geller is generally clip-oriented (if that makes sense; Noah Caldwell Gervais falls into this category in my head even though his work is extremely long-form). Folding Ideas has become a documentarian. Breadsword is "what happens if you have a clip for every word?"

    And you are the animator.

    in response to Who on YT would you say is doing videos most similar to yours, TARP-wise?

    Ian replied:

    what about the non-ARP vids that don't have a lot of animation??

  15. Published on Feb 28, 2024, 4:42 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    When writing a script for a video, do you ever worry about toeing the line between citation and appeal to authority? I've noticed that some essayists lean heavily into quotes. It seems like the vast majority of quotations in the works I typically engage with are oriented towards "quotes as supporting evidence" rather than "quotes as jumping off points for engaging with the arguments." Not that the former is necessarily worse than the latter (or even that they're well-defined terms). But I have occasionally come away from a video essay thinking that I could've just read the work they were quoting from and gotten the same value. Do you have any thoughts there?

    Ian replied:

    personally, no, I don't worry about that because I don't use a ton of quotes. I don't read that fast and I'm weird about always needing to feel like I have a NEW idea, a NEW perspective, that I don't like relying on other people's writing. there are individual videos that come CLOSE to being adaptations of a specific work - Always a Bigger Fish hews fairly close to The Reactionary Mind - but it's still being applied to my specific area of study and is loaded with my own applications of the author's theories and personal observations.

    but, like, that's one reason I can't maintain a monthly schedule!

    I think you are correct that some people - especially with an academic background - rely a lot more heavily on sources because "original research" is frowned upon in some circles. but also sometimes you're putting stuff out in volume and rely heavily on a specific source. PhilosophyTube started out just summarizing ideas from her grad school readings at a way of making information accessible, and I think that's what a number of us are shooting for. we are in a position to just research at a volume people with dayjobs often can't, so sharing what we learn is valuable even if there's not a TON of personal spin.

    and sometimes someone has just already said a thing well, and you wanna shine a light on them with your big platform. I know that one documentary on the antivax movement got a HUGE boost from Hbomb's video, and that's a good thing. so sometimes we're trying to serve as a 101 on a subject and highlight where you should go for more.

    but, yeah, if you're trying to produce 30-60 minutes every MONTH, I think you're gonna spend more time pointing at books on the subject and less time synthesizing the information and adding your own perspective. economics make anything else hard.

  16. Published on Feb 28, 2024, 3:56 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Lemme guess, Zodiac isn’t as deep or great or brilliant as we think it is, either, right?

    Ian replied:

    ...yeah

  17. Published on Feb 28, 2024, 3:55 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Hello! Big fan.

    Not sure if you get this question a lot (apologies if so) but I’m still a little fuzzy on the ending of The Cost of Doing Business. In it, you mention that a strong enough protest against the Provocateur would dissuade them from hosting the speaking engagement in the first place, beating them at their own power game.

    While I agree this is an effective method, is it not still weak to the whole “all publicity is good publicity” strategy? Just intuitively, it feels like the Provocateur’s end goal of “cause enough outrage that Fox News has to platform me and my awful ideas” is more than fulfilled by a thousand-people strong protest.

    While I understand that the point is to not play by their rules and refuse to accept their terms of “attention as a stake”, is there no middle ground? It seems like the Provocateur by his very existence forces the left into a compromising position, where we either let him spew hate and fuck with immigrants or give him the attention he’s chasing. Is there no way to win?

    Ian replied:

    that provocateur was based on Milo Yiannopoulos. heard from him lately? were his comments defending pedophilia "good publicity?"

  18. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 5:43 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Is Ted Cruz the Zodiac killer?

    Ian replied:

    I love the part at the end of the movie where Jake Gyllenhaal goes to a Ted Cruz rally and looks him in the eye knowingly

  19. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 5:33 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    You don't get engagement revenue from curious cat do ya?

    in response to Who on YT would you say is doing videos most similar to yours, TARP-wise?

    Ian replied:

    newppp

  20. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 5:33 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Given that Google is an absolute mess, maybe you can find some sort of resource that would explain that?
    Also... I'm not 100% sure the premise is accurate? "Europe" is just not very big unless you're including Scandinavia. If you did a measure of States/Territory-Area you may be surprised original anon.

    in response to Why do Europe and Africa have so many countries, rather than just a few big countries like in North America and Asia?

    Ian replied:

    I am shooting from the hip myself, but I think it boils down to "China big, Russia big, US big, Canada big," to which the follow-up question would be "how did they get so big?" and the answer in all cases is "they took a lot of land from a lot of people by force."

    we could look further into it, but that passes the sniff test!

  21. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 5:29 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Who on YT would you say is doing videos most similar to yours, TARP-wise?

    Ian replied:

    individual political videos have been similar to PhilosophyTube and Contrapoints, and gaming stuff has been similar to Errant Signal and Jacob Geller. probably the most overall similarity is to post-puppet, pre-feature-length-documentary Folding Ideas?

    but I'm a bad judge of these things. what do y'all think? who am I like?

  22. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 5:23 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What’s the difference between a revolution and a coup?

    Ian replied:

    one is an end and the other a means

  23. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 5:23 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Why are we pretending that Daffy doesn't give head?

    in response to Whaddaya got against Daffy?

    Ian replied:

    why are you pretending Daffy gives GOOD head?

  24. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 5:22 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    This anon forgot Smash 4

    in response to Ultimate Brawl Melee or Original?

    Ian replied:

    I'm fascinated by the question. I made one of the biggest videos about Melee on YouTube!

  25. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 5:22 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Who was the worst teacher you had in school?

    Ian replied:

    the history teacher who said that Sacajewa was a tribe

  26. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 2:17 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Why do Europe and Africa have so many countries, rather than just a few big countries like in North America and Asia?

    Ian replied:

    empire, I believe

  27. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 2:16 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Ultimate Brawl Melee or Original?

    in response to Bakunin or Marx?

    Ian replied:

    is this a real question

  28. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 2:16 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    The Martian Queen, Exactly Once, and it's canon.

    in response to Whaddaya got against Daffy?

    Ian replied:

    well I'm not her, so

  29. Published on Feb 26, 2024, 2:16 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    ░P░R░O░N░O░U░N░S░ ░I░N░ ░P░U░S░S░Y░

    in response to ░P░U░S░S░Y░ ░I░N░ ░B░I░O░

    Ian replied:

    ░P░R░O░N░O░U░N░S░ ░A░R░E░ ░P░U░/░S░S░Y░

  30. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 11:56 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Do you think life is pretty good in the developed world rn, minus climate change and wars abroad?

    Ian replied:

    compared to what

  31. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 11:55 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    You have been hit on the head by a comically large mallet.

    in response to Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck, or Bugs Bunny in drag?

    Ian replied:

    hot

  32. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 11:55 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Bakunin or Marx?

    Ian replied:

    smash both

  33. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 11:55 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Yeah but by that logic your content or those of other progressive channels haven’t done much either.

    in response to Second Thought is the largest socialist channel and he’s an ML.

    Ian replied:

    I don't see how that's relevant to the conversation we're having

  34. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 11:54 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What about 'em?

    in response to And is 40 fuckin' you back?

    Ian replied:

    creaky

  35. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 11:54 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    ░P░U░S░S░Y░ ░I░N░ ░B░I░O░

    Ian replied:

    ░T░H░A░T░S░ ░W░H░E░R░E░ ░Y░O░U░R░ ░P░R░O░N░O░U░N░S░ ░G░O░

  36. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 11:51 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What rules should people follow for age gaps in relationships? Cause clearly you aren't okay with the "half your age + 7" rule.

    in response to Tom Holland is 27 years old.

    Ian replied:

    you don't have to extrapolate my preferences into a rule for other people. we can say banging people my own age is my weird kink, whatever.

  37. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 11:48 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Whaddaya got against Daffy?

    in response to Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck, or Bugs Bunny in drag?

    Ian replied:

    I'm sorry, do you think Daffy Duck has ever once in his life given another person pleasure?

  38. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 10:02 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    And is 40 fuckin' you back?

    in response to Tom Holland is 27 years old.

    Ian replied:

    every day. can we talk about my fuckin knees?

  39. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 4:40 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    what do u like about it

    in response to Really? I mean, it's good and all, but it's no King Lear.

    Ian replied:

    I dunno, his later plays that are kind of comedies and kind of romances and like of dramas just hit for me. I like reading Prospero as an author insert, the old magician begging his audience's pardon for one last indulgence, one last go-round. Caliban is not UNproblematic but there is SOME critique of colonialism in how he's written, and some just beautiful speeches. I dunno, it just hits a lot of the right buttons.

  40. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 4:35 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Is it necessarily wrong that I think all of those things are art, or at least contain art? Maybe my definition is over-broad but I think anything made or curated with the intention of evoking a feeling in an audience is art. Video games all apply, warning labels can apply because they evoke fear or caution(or attempt to), textbooks vary but like...my american history textbooks certainly were trying to evoke nationalism or empathy at varying times, occasionally wonder. Microsoft Word as a whole is the least art thing as its a tool but it's not as if it's entirely function without consideration of form.

    But I also just don't think something being art or not is a value statement for me. It's a weird discussion to have when you could just instead discuss the form or intent or effectiveness at those things, to me.

    in response to (different anon) I think the blanket-ness of the question is where the problem lies. There are games that already exist that I would say are unquestionably art. I played Spiritfarer shortly after my dad died and it gave me FEELINGS. There are also games that I would say are not art (not BAD art, just not-art). Much the same way that not everything written down is art, but no one is trying to argue that Asimov or Wordsworth aren't. I think it's also worth noting that not everything that's written or recorded in other media is TRYING to be art. We also have, say, journalism. Likewise, I think there are games that have no intention of being art, but that doesn't diminish the artistic value of the games that are.

    Ian replied:

    I think any of those CAN be art, as Duchamp tried to demonstrate with the ReadiMades over a century ago: take a thing that is NOT meant to provoke an aesthetic response, put it in a gallery, and suddenly it DOES provoke an aesthetic response, even if that response is rejection. I think warning labels are generally not considered art solely because neither the people making them nor the ones consuming them are considering it in that context, but all they would have to do is think about it differently to become art.

    video games, though... I don't think the context in which people experience Call of Duty is meaningfully different from that of Passage; it's all aesthetics, even if the aesthetics are different.

  41. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 4:31 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck, or Bugs Bunny in drag?

    in response to Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, or Tom Holland?

    Ian replied:

    smash, pass, smash

  42. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 4:30 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Tom Holland is 27 years old.

    in response to Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, or Tom Holland?

    Ian replied:

    yeah and I'm fuckin 40

  43. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 4:30 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    So...... you finally saw it.

    in response to Have you seen the Mario movie yet?

    Ian replied:

    I was babysitting and was told the kid liked it

  44. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 4:30 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Different anon. What exactly counts as Zionism? It was originally defined as the idea that there should be a home for the Jews in the Levant, and that doesn’t seem like too much of a problem. The problem is when it becomes a home for ONLY Jews. The most expansive form of this is revisionist Zionism and that postulates that not only are Jews and only Jews entitled all the traditional land of Israel, they are entitled to take control of it by whatever means necessary. Revisionist Zionism is the official ideology of the Likud Party, but is it the official definition of Zionism?

    in response to I got two questions: One: When people talk about defunding the police, are they talking the ENTIRE system (like state troopers and others) or are they just talking the ones we think of when people say police (people in blue outfits in cities who have guns on them). Feel like driving is getting worse, but that's probably because I live in a city where driving is basically required #freeandaccessiblepublictransport Two: Is Zionism a bad idea? I've read about for my AP European History class, and my conclusion is "yeah, I completely understand where this is coming from...but it leads to an ethnostate, so I think it's bad." Is that just because of the current state of Isreal, or has CollegeBoard whitewashed some of the context?

    Ian replied:

    with the caveat that I am, again, coming from a place of incomplete knowledge: I don't see a way to make a space explicitly for Jews that doesn't turn into an ethnostate. the US was first colonized by Protestants fleeing religious persecution, but in no way do I think this nation would be better if it were codified as an expressly Protestant nation, and every American who thinks it should have been is morally bankrupt. people fleeing religious persecution should found a nation on religious liberty, not just making a theocracy for their own religion that will, by its very nature, trend towards persecuting other religions.

    the fact that the descendents of people displaced by genocide founded their country on displacing others whom they are now genociding is horrendous. because they didn't defend against displacement or genocide; Zionism only defends Zionists.

  45. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 4:23 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Thoughts on the Starship Troopers movie?

    Ian replied:

    slaps

  46. Published on Feb 25, 2024, 4:22 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Second Thought is the largest socialist channel and he’s an ML.

    in response to Tankies are gaining significant traction in the online left. I feel that people have become so disillusioned with capitalism and American hegemony that they're willing to get behind any other government or cause that opposes it. Stalin apologia is getting really common (Holodomor denial, purges were justified, etc.), along with victim blaming anyone who opposes or fled a country like China, Russia, or Cuba as either a C.I.A. agent or a rich right-wing gusano. Second Thought even made a video recently that was basically just 20 minutes of anti-American propaganda without any mention of the good the United States has done, or the far worse things that America's enemies do.

    Ian replied:

    the influence of YouTubers on actual socialist organizing in this country is almost nil

  47. Published on Feb 24, 2024, 9:15 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I got two questions:
    One: When people talk about defunding the police, are they talking the ENTIRE system (like state troopers and others) or are they just talking the ones we think of when people say police (people in blue outfits in cities who have guns on them). Feel like driving is getting worse, but that's probably because I live in a city where driving is basically required #freeandaccessiblepublictransport

    Two: Is Zionism a bad idea? I've read about for my AP European History class, and my conclusion is "yeah, I completely understand where this is coming from...but it leads to an ethnostate, so I think it's bad." Is that just because of the current state of Isreal, or has CollegeBoard whitewashed some of the context?

    Ian replied:

    1) generally, if people are saying "defund" rather than "abolish," they are suggesting we keep the system but reduce its budget. most have a list of things they'd say we should cut first (let's start with the FUCKING TANKS). different people may have different ideas for what should be reduced and by how much, and there may even be entire departments they'd like cut, but BY AND LARGE it's not a radical overhaul of the concept, just the scope.

    2) I could also stand to read more about Israel, but my starting position is "Zionism is a very bad idea and we are currently seeing why," and it would take A LOT of convincing for me to consider that there's an ethical version of it.

  48. Published on Feb 24, 2024, 9:09 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, or Tom Holland?

    Ian replied:

    smash, smash, pass (too young)

  49. Published on Feb 24, 2024, 9:08 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    (different anon)
    I think the blanket-ness of the question is where the problem lies. There are games that already exist that I would say are unquestionably art. I played Spiritfarer shortly after my dad died and it gave me FEELINGS. There are also games that I would say are not art (not BAD art, just not-art). Much the same way that not everything written down is art, but no one is trying to argue that Asimov or Wordsworth aren't.

    I think it's also worth noting that not everything that's written or recorded in other media is TRYING to be art. We also have, say, journalism. Likewise, I think there are games that have no intention of being art, but that doesn't diminish the artistic value of the games that are.

    in response to I've always kinda hated the question "are video games art" because it feels like "art" is so often used as a covert synonym for "respectable." Like the question feels like someone looking for validation of a hobby traditionally seen as childish, desperate to prove that they're not as lame as they (are secretly afraid they) are for playing video games. I love video essays and discussions about game design and whatnot. If I had to answer the original question, I'd go with "sure." But I dunno, that question "are video games art" just kinda reads as quietly desperate and seeking for approval, and I guess that irks me. Thoughts?

    Ian replied:

    I agree with you - to a degree - on intentionality being part of what makes art art, but I don't see any rubric for why SOME games are art and others are not, since most games are made using similar processes and similar limitations. (by which I mean: Spiritfarer and Fortnite are far more similar to each other then either is to, like, a Goya painting.)

    there is writing that is not (primarily) art because it does not put itself in an artistic context. I wouldn't exclude journalism, necessarily, but, like... warning labels. signage. textbooks and homework assignments. a movie is art but is the description on the back of the Blu-Ray art?

    but I would say that's the difference between a video game and, like, Microsoft Word. software is to text what a video game is to a novel - the medium and the form.

    what makes games art has more to do with the CAPACITY to make you feel something, to have substance, to express something, than with whether a single game is successful at it, or even attempting it. I might even argue the pursuit of "mere" entertainment is still an artistic pursuit. it's just a generally derided one.

  50. Published on Feb 24, 2024, 8:53 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    True. It was very silly that there wasn't an option to disable those, especially with unused buttons available.

    What about the motion controls in Metroid Prime 3?

    in response to You probably were thinking of fitness games but my mind immediately went to Donkey Kong Country Returns

    Ian replied:

    I didn't play Prime 3

  51. Published on Feb 24, 2024, 8:52 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    "When I was a teenager, some friends of the family would invite me along when they asked my parents to dinner, because I would play with their five-year-old and let the grown-ups chat in peace. And he’d make up games where we’d bat a balloon back and forth or whatever, and change the rules on the fly when it suited him. Because the rule wasn’t actually 'you can only touch the balloon once per turn;' the rule was 'Andrew wins.' "

    Is something similar going on here? Like, gamers will say "games are art" when it makes them feel better about themselves, but then turn around and say "it's just a game, stop taking it so seriously" when Anita looks at games as art and uses a feminist lens? Because the question isn't "are games art?" but rather "what makes me feel better about myself in the moment"?

    in response to I've always kinda hated the question "are video games art" because it feels like "art" is so often used as a covert synonym for "respectable." Like the question feels like someone looking for validation of a hobby traditionally seen as childish, desperate to prove that they're not as lame as they (are secretly afraid they) are for playing video games. I love video essays and discussions about game design and whatnot. If I had to answer the original question, I'd go with "sure." But I dunno, that question "are video games art" just kinda reads as quietly desperate and seeking for approval, and I guess that irks me. Thoughts?

    Ian replied:

    yes

  52. Published on Feb 24, 2024, 12:57 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    You probably were thinking of fitness games but my mind immediately went to Donkey Kong Country Returns

    in response to What is your least favorite way to Run in video games from a controller input standpoint. For me I can't stand having to double tap a direction to run

    Ian replied:

    no, they make sense in fitness games. I did NOT like the obligatory motion controls in Mario Odyssey.

  53. Published on Feb 24, 2024, 12:31 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I've always kinda hated the question "are video games art" because it feels like "art" is so often used as a covert synonym for "respectable." Like the question feels like someone looking for validation of a hobby traditionally seen as childish, desperate to prove that they're not as lame as they (are secretly afraid they) are for playing video games.

    I love video essays and discussions about game design and whatnot. If I had to answer the original question, I'd go with "sure." But I dunno, that question "are video games art" just kinda reads as quietly desperate and seeking for approval, and I guess that irks me.

    Thoughts?

    Ian replied:

    that's a thing, but I've at least as often heard the reverse: games are NOT art and therefore not beholden to the same critical lenses as art; they are consumer products and should be tailored to the desires of the customer, not a means for artists to express themselves.

    more than anything, I think gamers wanna say "the jury's still out" on whether games are art, like they WANT it to be art SOMEDAY but for now we gotta keep arguing about it, and until it's settled they can still be entitled little shits about it.

  54. Published on Feb 24, 2024, 12:25 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    The point of the "worst game" question is to share what's your kinda trash. What you stuck with even though you had misgivings and broad choice.
    I think the "worst" game I cleared via emulator was Bahamut Lagoon?

    Ian replied:

    Toejam n Earl: Panic on Funkotron

  55. Published on Feb 23, 2024, 7:42 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What did you tweet on October 7?

    Ian replied:

    I wasn't on Twitter October 7th

  56. Published on Feb 23, 2024, 12:17 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Do you have a portable emulator or do you emulate on your PC?

    in response to Thoughts on video game emulation?

    Ian replied:

    PC

  57. Published on Feb 23, 2024, 12:16 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Original Anon: I do want to clarify that I definitely don't think that storming government buildings is an effective strategy.

    There's one strategy that I've been thinking has potential: Convince airline pilots and/or other airport workers to go on strike so as to shut down flights across the country, and keep them shut down until elected officials meet our demands. Withholding certain types of labor that the ruling class depend on can be a powerful technique.

    in response to (diff anon) It wouldn't take much "legwork" for progressives to storm the capital if Trump is reelected. It just takes the will.

    Ian replied:

    general strikes are appealing, I agree. just understand they will definitely send cops to beat the shit out of people on strike. it's a not a shortcut to nonviolence.

  58. Published on Feb 23, 2024, 12:15 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What is your least favorite way to Run in video games from a controller input standpoint. For me I can't stand having to double tap a direction to run

    Ian replied:

    motion controls

  59. Published on Feb 23, 2024, 1:44 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Thinking about old SNES games makes me sad. But also, now I want to hear what's the worst game you emulated - but also played to an ending screen.

    Ian replied:

    I don't think I played any emulated games to the end if they were bad - too easy to switch to something else. now, Genesis games that I OWNED and therefore didn't have a lot of options? Toy Story, probably.

  60. Published on Feb 23, 2024, 1:40 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Really? I mean, it's good and all, but it's no King Lear.

    in response to Space Invaders, Asteroids, or Galaga?

    Ian replied:

    ok this is funny cuz The Tempest actually IS my favorite Shakespeare...

  61. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 11:09 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    I've asked "ideal horse" every so often I come here and yet, I've never seen it pop up. Are you never going to tell me

    Ian replied:

    Sleipnir

  62. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:33 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Do you like Kraftwerk?

    Ian replied:

    sure

  63. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:30 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Is this guy implying that not understanding how to take care of your children and understand their needs is a good and attractive quality??? I mean I know the answer to that is yes but it's still strange to see it so blatantly. What a baffling worldview

    in response to Women are physically attracted strong men who can hunt for food and provide healthy offspring. Women are more empathetic to care for young. Would you trust Justin Bieber to prevent you from getting mauled by a tiger? Would you expect Hulk Hogan or Clint Eastwood to take care of children and understand their needs well?

    Ian replied:

    it's also absolutely not borne out by observing animal populations. "alpha males" do NOT genetically out-compete "nice guys."

  64. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:29 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    what you been playing lately?

    Ian replied:

    just finished Blasphemous II, then played a buncha Next Fest demos

  65. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:29 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Sometimes I wonder how much of the "violent revolution today" talk in the online left is just memeing and how much of it is people who actually think that a socialist revolution in the US right now wouldn't just immediately lead to every participant getting put down by the largest, most industrialized military in the world and an immediate surge in support for reactionary, if not outright facist, policies by like 90% of the public

    in response to (diff anon) It wouldn't take much "legwork" for progressives to storm the capital if Trump is reelected. It just takes the will.

    Ian replied:

    I think most of them believe that some kinda details would be ironed out in the process, though I think they underestimate how, uh... complicated... planning a revolution is

  66. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:25 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Should you never call the police when someone is having a mental health crisis?

    Ian replied:

    I'm not in charge of this. there may be a scenario where you can't think of a better option. generally, I would call paramedics, cuz they can't shoot anybody.

  67. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:23 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Have recommendations?

    in response to Thoughts on video game emulation?

    Ian replied:

    Chrono Trigger and Terranigma

  68. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:22 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    So I was rewatching your cuck CO-VID (one of my questions is what made you make it, it feels to me like its one part a lost Alt-Right Playbook episode and another part airing annoyances about their claims about your personal life, and you say you try to keep your personal life distant from online, which is completely valid), and I'm wondering what we stole mathematics from, since you mention that near the end of the video.

    Ian replied:

    a lot of math comes from Asia and the Middle East

  69. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:22 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    What's the best movie adaption of a video game?

    Ian replied:

    Pirates of the Caribbean is a loose but fairly faithful adaptation of The Secret of Monkey Island

  70. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:20 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    favorite amusement park you've been to

    Ian replied:

    I'm a devotee of the Santa Cruz Beach Boardwalk

  71. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:19 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    best cool math game

    Ian replied:

    Frog Fractions

  72. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 10:19 PM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Space Invaders, Asteroids, or Galaga?

    Ian replied:

    Tempest

  73. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 1:19 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Tankies are gaining significant traction in the online left. I feel that people have become so disillusioned with capitalism and American hegemony that they're willing to get behind any other government or cause that opposes it. Stalin apologia is getting really common (Holodomor denial, purges were justified, etc.), along with victim blaming anyone who opposes or fled a country like China, Russia, or Cuba as either a C.I.A. agent or a rich right-wing gusano. Second Thought even made a video recently that was basically just 20 minutes of anti-American propaganda without any mention of the good the United States has done, or the far worse things that America's enemies do.

    in response to How do I argue with tankies better?

    Ian replied:

    are they actually gaining traction or are they just showing up in your feeds more?

  74. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 1:18 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Thoughts on legislation outlawing predatory monetization like microtransactions and lootboxes? The idea, I dunno if there's any actual legislation out there.

    Ian replied:

    I mean, if we're going to have capitalism, I am generally in favor of the law having an antagonistic relationship with it. any time predatory practices are reigned in, that's a net gain.

  75. Published on Feb 22, 2024, 1:17 AM

    A

    Anonymous commented:

    Thoughts on video game emulation?

    Ian replied:

    I wouldn't know a bunch of my favorite games without it!

Anon commented:
Ian replied:

CuriousCat is an anonymous Q&A social networking site. It is set to be discontinued on Oct 7, 2024.

This is an archive of the 15094 questions and answers from my CuriousCat page.

Previous Next

Site Credit: Arpit Agrawal