in response to I don't think the All-Beef Diet guy is kind to animals
in response to I don't think the All-Beef Diet guy is kind to animals
Anonymous commented:
there is a line in his "12 rules for life" where one of the rules is literally ro pet a can if you meet them out in the street right?
in response to I don't think the All-Beef Diet guy is kind to animals
Ian replied:
I haven't pet enough cans
Anonymous commented:
ah, but consider: beef is second only to lamb in terms of environmental devastation per serving. other meats aren't nearly as fast at accelerating global ecological collapse
in response to I don't think the All-Beef Diet guy is kind to animals
Ian replied:
we are not discussing whether an all-beef diet is good for the environment, only if it is kind to non-cow animals. as a vegan, I do not need to be convinced that eating beef is, in other ways, bad.
Anonymous commented:
I don't think the All-Beef Diet guy is kind to animals
Ian replied:
look he only eats ONE animal, which is much kinder to the rest of the animal kingdom than most omnivores
Anonymous commented:
when she was still with us my mom would often go for green juice and i still don't know what the fuck it's even for
Ian replied:
it's for getting fruits and vegetables in your body when your breakfast is all carbs and protein
Anonymous commented:
Is debating a waste of time?
Ian replied:
not wholly, but it is, in my opinion, high risk and of marginal benefit. people have gotten good results out of it, but I don't think there are enough people on the Left who are both good at it and the kinds of people we'd want shaping the discourse.
Anonymous commented:
What would you do if your son was a Peterson fan?
in response to Do you think Jordan Peterson is a bad person?
Ian replied:
the idea that Peterson will still be A Thing in the time it would take for me to have a child and raise him to the age of Peterson's demographic is laughable
Anonymous commented:
what do you usually do for breakfast? most of my go-to breakfasts have dairy, so i feel like unless you're using a non-dairy milk with cereal your options are bread and not much else, at least for typical american breakfast food
Ian replied:
Bagel with Tofutti cream cheese and Spike, some field roast breakfast sausages, and a cup of Irish breakfast tea with oat milk. Sometimes some green juice.
Anonymous commented:
Ok chud what's your problem with the white race?
Ian replied:
for starters we invented the concept of "the white race" which hasn't really resulted in anything positive
Anonymous commented:
Was John McCain the only good Republican?
Ian replied:
no he was a prick as well
Anonymous commented:
(different anon) Why don't you think in those terms? I don't much care for that dichotomy either, but it's been kind of difficult for me to articulate why.
in response to Do you think Jordan Peterson is a bad person?
Ian replied:
I find that debating the absolute value of a person's character is almost never productive, because I don't know what Peterson is like in his free time or whether he's kind to animals or what kind of private thoughts go on in his head. saying "this person is bad to his core" is discussing how many angels can dance on a pin. but I can demonstrate pretty irrefutably that what he is DOING causes harm. and hurting people, is prick behavior.
Anonymous commented:
(different anon) Honestly, even in the absence of evidence I'd be willing to believe that the conquistadors raped indigenous women. An invading/occupying/colonizing force using sexual violence as a tool of subjugation is something with a *lot* of historical precedent.
Ian replied:
yes, indeed, but also WE HAVE EVIDENCE
Anonymous commented:
It may not reflect the aims of socialism directly, but socialism doesn't develop in a vacuum. State power is necessary in order to defend the revolution from imperialism (historically from Nazi Germany in WW2, or the United States and its allies during the Cold War) and potentially spread it to neighboring countries to eventually achieve proletarian internationalism. Fledgling socialist countries that don't consolidate their revolutions get overthrown (as in Allede's Chile and Sankara's Burkina Faso) or reformed back to capitalism (as in China, Vietnam, and eventually the Soviet Union.)
Che Guevara himself witnessed the United States overthrow Guatemala's democratically elected socialist Jacobo Arbenz and the failed Bay of Pigs invasion to overthrow Fidel Castro, which was what cemented in his mind the need for state and military power to fight against imperialism. That was why he permitted Soviets to bring missiles to Cuba, culminating in the Cuban Missile Crisis.
in response to why is that? (diff anon)
Ian replied:
state and military power justified to "fight imperialism" just results in another long-standing hierarchical power structure. my aim as a leftist is to abolish capitalism for being such a structure, not shift that power back to the state. and, as an American, I live in the only country that could turn socialist and NOT worry about being overthrown by the US.
Anonymous commented:
i don't know shit about les mis except that i know the first song slaps. if i want to watch a good version, what should i go for?
Ian replied:
Tenth Anniversary concert edition.
Anonymous commented:
Do you think Jordan Peterson is a bad person?
Ian replied:
I don't think so much in terms of "good person/bad person," but he's a prick
Anonymous commented:
(Different anon) Am I missing something here? What’s so wrong with that logic?
Ian replied:
diddling altar boys also goes against their religion, turns out PEOPLE SIN
Anonymous commented:
why is that? (diff anon)
in response to Are you a Marxist–Leninist?
Ian replied:
I don't agree that the consolidation of that much state power reflects the aims of socialism
Anonymous commented:
Did you ever drive down that one really swirly street?
Ian replied:
Lombard? I don't remember if I ever drove it. Walked it a couple times.
Anonymous commented:
You can't just say "Pride and Prejudice." Are we talking the 1940 movie? The 1995 miniseries?! The 2005 movie?!! The original novel on microfiche?!?
in response to Are you gonna watch the Super Bowl tonight?
Ian replied:
'95 obviously
Anonymous commented:
Are you gonna do an ARP about how people just, assert there's no evidence despite it being incredibly easy to find?
Ian replied:
i swear to god
Anonymous commented:
Can I call you Haunchy
Ian replied:
just don't call me late for dinner
Anonymous commented:
Are you gonna watch the Super Bowl tonight?
Ian replied:
I think we're gonna watch pride and prejudice tonight
Anonymous commented:
And did you think of it?
Ian replied:
yeah
Anonymous commented:
What's the worst job you've had?
Ian replied:
I spent one day filing at a bank, where you had to take a paper from a stack and enter it into a system, and the process was so involved that, on my first 8-hour shift, the one I started still wasn't done at the end of the workday, and nobody smiled or talked to each other and the lights were this horrible yellow fluorescent
I quit the very next day
Anonymous commented:
Which is more important: equality or liberty?
Ian replied:
you can't have true liberty without equality, and vice versa
Anonymous commented:
You ever stayed at the YMCA then?
in response to Have you ever had to go hungry?
Ian replied:
no. I lived in low-income housing that can't easily evict people for being eight months behind in rent, so when I finally got a job I just cashed every check immediately and gave it directly to my landlord until I was caught up. I lived off my food stamps and only kept two paychecks for myself for the better part of a year.
I should stress that, having been raised middle class, I was the only broke person I knew, so I had access to a lot of resources that people RAISED in poverty don't have. I had people to lend me money when the debt collectors called, I could be professional at a weekend temp job because I talked like a middle class person, there were always couches to sleep on and people with cars when I needed them. I was never going to end up in the street.
Anonymous commented:
This anon has a point tho. Why *would* conquistadors rape the Natives if they had wives and doing so would go against the religion they’re preaching?
Ian replied:
are you FUCKING SERIOUS RIGHT NOW
Anonymous commented:
Who will lead the revolution?
Ian replied:
I nominate weird al
Anonymous commented:
Why are markets in general bad?
Ian replied:
the basic market exchange, where goods and services are traded for money such that the material labor of the provider, the material need of the consumer, and the material substance of the good, are abstracted into vague, mutable notions of "price" and "value" that are meant to be negotiated, such that value is "agreed upon" despite labor, need, and substance being fixed, so that each party in the exchange must treat their own needs flexible because "price" always fluctuates, is dubious
this exchange being subservient to "market forces" so that, if supply exceeds demand the provider is at a disadvantage and if demand exceeds supply the consumer is at a disadvantage, so that in nearly all cases the negotiation takes place on unequal footing, is deeply suspect
a system in which nearly all goods and services, even basic necessities like food and shelter, must be purchased through such a market, and where any exchange that is still based on trading goods and services purely based on need and labor (like, say, sharing digital art online) is simply a "potential market" waiting to be monetized, and being at too great a disadvantage in these exchanges means not having basic needs met and often enough leads to poverty and even death, is unethical
every single such market being interconnected to the point where the movement of money has long divorced itself from the actual needs of workers and consumers, such that entities like "angel investors" and "shareholders" influence the market far more than people who actually buy or sell things within it, and a business is "successful" even if it operates at a loss because investors pump money into it and every time they fire a ton of workers their stock goes up because it's PERCEIVED as cost-saving (even though everyone knows they have never turned a profit) and the largest products are getting worse year by year because shareholders and investors are the sources of income that matter even though those people don't actually produce anything and these companies are so big that if they failed it would crash the entire economy for everyone... is catastrophic
Anonymous commented:
Have you ever been to San Francisco? What did you think of it?
Ian replied:
I lived in San Francisco for 3 years.
Anonymous commented:
What about people who don’t wear hats?
in response to What is the first thing you notice about a person?
Ian replied:
I don't notice them. I'm unconvinced they exist.
Anonymous commented:
Yes I'm being serious. If there really were mass rapes during the colonization of the Americas, it should have been well documented in the same way the slave trade was. But I can't find any source detailing such a phenomenon. And weren't ~90% of the natives in South America and the Caribbean killed off by diseases? Even if they were raped and impregnated, the chances those children would be able to grow up healthy enough to reach adulthood would be slim. To say that it happened enough to shape the bloodline of an ENTIRE CONTINENT'S population all the way to their present-day descendants is some True Romance shit.
Ian replied:
weird that you couldn't find anything when this is the first hit on google for me
Anonymous commented:
Are you a Marxist–Leninist?
Ian replied:
no
Anonymous commented:
Have you ever had to go hungry?
Ian replied:
"going hungry" can mean a lot of things, from eating disorders to decades of malnutrition due to generational poverty.
during the recession when I was underemployed and had no degree and my food stamps hadn't cleared I had a food budget of about $25 a week and lived off pancakes and lentil soup. at one point I had $7 in the bank. I dropped to 115 pounds.
that is the hungriest I have gone.
Anonymous commented:
What is the first thing you notice about a person?
Ian replied:
their hat
Anonymous commented:
What’s the weirdest crush you’ve had?
Ian replied:
in high school I had a crush on a girl in my math class named Aris and I told my friend about it cuz he was in the same class but he thought I meant Aeris from Final Fantasy VII and for like multiple days he thought my current crush was a character from a game I didn't even own and gave me very weird looks
he eventually put two and two together (cuz it was math class get it?)
Anonymous commented:
What song have you got on repeat lately?
Ian replied:
uhhhhh...
once and for all from the disney musical newsies
Anonymous commented:
Would you rather have money or fame?
Ian replied:
no
Anonymous commented:
Just came across this post.. Is it true that the ancestors of Latin Americans were raped by white Europeans? Like, wouldn’t that have been a sin for the Catholic Spaniards that sailed to the new world to spread their religion? Didn’t they have wives at home? I would like a source please.
Ian replied:
are you fucking serious right now
Anonymous commented:
Have jokes about Betteridge's Law gotten stale over the years?
Ian replied:
certainly not as stale as "friends we made along the way" jokes, which are entirely stock at this point
Anonymous commented:
Looking at things and people OBJECTIVELY or SUBJECTIVELY ?
Ian replied:
it's impossible to look at anything objectively, which is why it's valuable to consider many subjective perspectives - both yours and others' - to try and approximate an objective reality
Anonymous commented:
Do you want your organs donated when you die?
Ian replied:
why wait??
Anonymous commented:
define spoopy
in response to Have you played any of the Silent Hill games?
Ian replied:
boo!
Anonymous commented:
Have you watched any movies this week?
Ian replied:
if your week starts on Sunday, yes: I watched Birdman
if your week starts on Monday, no, but I'm seeing Magic Mike's Last Dance on Saturday
Anonymous commented:
What artist or band do you always recommend when someone asks for a music recommendation?
Ian replied:
depends on their tastes, but people almost always appreciate hearing Balrog Boogie for the first time: https://open.spotify.com/track/65RptVLH4KdgCeEAuPS8WY?si=801e96439c9841c5
Anonymous commented:
I am a stalinist
Ian replied:
you can get a lotion for that
Anonymous commented:
What has the Alt-Right even accomplished? I doubt the average person has ever heard of the term.
Ian replied:
well a number of people are dead because of them, which is a pretty big impact
Anonymous commented:
How many people can you name on the album cover of Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band?
Ian replied:
I have named them all Tommy
Anonymous commented:
Are you using ChatGPT to speed up your work? I strongly recommend it; its applications are incredibly broad
Ian replied:
elaborate, please
Anonymous commented:
Ion Danskin
Ian replied:
y'all are on FIRE
Anonymous commented:
ponker face
in response to what do you think of poker face so far (if you started it)?
Ian replied:
damn
Anonymous commented:
Have you played any of the Silent Hill games?
Ian replied:
no, too spoopy
Anonymous commented:
Out of the Lynch movies you have seen, what do you think is his best?
Ian replied:
uhhhhh
the one I dislike the least is Blue Velvet, the one that I would probably like the most if I liked his stuff is Mulholland Drive
Anonymous commented:
How long is it until podcasts start getting porn parodies
Ian replied:
WelCUM to Night Vale?
Anonymous commented:
LEMON DEMON???
Ian replied:
yeah doy
Anonymous commented:
(Different anon) would the country change its name from being the United Kingdom to something else? What could be its new name?
Ian replied:
I mean they already use Great Britain and The British Isles, they can probably just redefine one of those
Anonymous commented:
Why Ventura?
Ian replied:
are we doing anything better with ventura?
Anonymous commented:
how often do you get asked questions about weird al yankovic
Ian replied:
not often enough!
Anonymous commented:
Would anyone else who we've reason to believe would be hazardous to people also have ventura or would different groups who would be hazardous to people in different ways go to different locations?
Ian replied:
puppy kickers go in hot air balloons floating over ventura
Anonymous commented:
where do you sit on the classification of smash as a fighting game? i feel like, even though there's a lot of overlap in the community and culture of fighting games, anyone can take a look at smash, then take a look at any number of fighting games and say pretty confidently that it's not a fighting game
Ian replied:
I guess I would question your question: what do we gain by defining it as other than a fighting game? what does the lens "fighting game" open us up to? how is our understanding or appreciation of Smash changed if it is something other than a fighting game? I've been reading a lot of essays about film noir lately and you'd be shocked by how many entire essays are just arguing about whether film noir is a genre vs. a movement vs. a style, and they always beg the question of why the distinction matters. are there tools of analysis closed off to us if we limit noir to "genre" or Smash to "fighting game"? or is it just fun to argue about, like whether Die Hard is a Christmas movie?
Anonymous commented:
Are men who like trans women (not exclusively) considered straight and vice versa for trans men?
Ian replied:
what they're "considered" is irrelevant: if you are a man attracted solely to women, you're straight.
Anonymous commented:
Why don’t you like David Lynch’s work?
Ian replied:
I could give you my complaints but they don't matter. because everyone who loves him knows the complaints: the acting is weird, the movies kinda feel like they're gonna make sense but they never do, his fascination with women sometimes reads like a horny teenager simultaneously obsessed with and terrified of sex. in the end, most fans can hear those critiques and agree with them, or agree to disagree, but they don't change anything because Lynch's movies have a vibe. and none of that gets in the way of the vibe; hell, they're PART of the vibe. and the vibe is unlike anything else out there.
his vibe doesn't work on me. I respect it, and him, and people who love him. but I can't stand watching his movies.
Anonymous commented:
True, but there are a significant number of murderers in prisons. They should be somewhere better than prisons, but they shouldn’t just be released.
in response to if we abolish prisons what do we do with murderers?
Ian replied:
they can have ventura
Anonymous commented:
When do you estimate the next video will come?
Ian replied:
finished the rough cut today, you can see it now on Patreon. got some bits to work out still so dunno when it'll go public.
Anonymous commented:
Maccas order
Ian replied:
chronological
Anonymous commented:
do you like being spooked
Ian replied:
not at all
Anonymous commented:
How would Britain abolish the monarchy? A vote in Parliament or something?
Ian replied:
that's preferable to the guillotine, yeah
Anonymous commented:
what's your take on the choking/abuse kink discourse?
Ian replied:
let's pretend I'm not up-to-date on the kink discourse and explain what the argument is
you know
for the readers
Anonymous commented:
if we abolish prisons what do we do with murderers?
Ian replied:
I think you overestimate how many murderers end up in jail
Anonymous commented:
Does it bring you some peace to know your content has deradicalized people?
Ian replied:
it makes me very happy! enough people have told me so that I know it's not a fluke, but I have no idea how much it happens. I've had a couple dozen confirmed cases; is that most of it, or the tip of the iceberg? so I have a hard time thinking of myself as "a guy who deradicalizes people," and I don't know how much of that is my chronic aversion to taking credit for things. the idea that I'm having THAT MUCH impact on people's lives is daunting. while I've always kept "if an unhappy conservative saw this, how would it be useful to them?" in the back of my mind, it's never been my target audience. I've geared my stuff very explicitly to a presumed-Left audience. and, you know, there's a persuasive power to treating people like they already agree with your position, sometimes more effective than trying to convince them of it. but it's not the AIM. and if it's happening anyway? that's awesome! but does knowing that change the way I make it? if not, should it? do my responsibilities shift? in what ways? and then it's oh god oh god, am I to take this ring to Mordor?
but yes. happy!
Anonymous commented:
Italo Calvino, thoughts
Ian replied:
The Distance of the Moon is possibly my favorite short story
Anonymous commented:
Is Die Hard a Christmas movie?
Anonymous commented:
How is your back feeling?
Ian replied:
it keeps developing new issues but nothing serious or debilitating
Anonymous commented:
what do you think of poker face so far (if you started it)?
Ian replied:
who doesn't want Natasha Lyonne as Vagrant Columbo?
Anonymous commented:
Did you miss us 🥺
Ian replied:
yeah 💙
Anonymous commented:
"Jordan Peterson lives on low-quality beef"
"yeah but what does he eat?"
*shave and a haircut*